I MUST reincarnate Sadie. I have an amazing plot idea for it. I still have the slot for a Shadow cat available, she can be reincarnated into one of those. *Scratches Desperately* I SHALL GIVETH THOU A COOKIE IF I CAN REINCARNATE HER!!!
I know that StarHerd wouldn't have enough power, but I am a member of the Reborn club (Eh, I'm founding it anyway), meaning that I beleive that Cinderpaw is really Cinderpelt reincarnated into another cat by StarClan. If StarClan could do it, why not StarHerd? I really need to reincarnate Sadie. LEMMEH DO IT!!! PLZPLZPLZ!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Detective Squeaker: You actually used chatspeak? Wow, you're desperate.
Mumble: Shut up.
Well, I semi-reincarnated TigerClaw. She's like a ghost of some sort... I dunno. But if you get to - we do too :P.
Well, not exactly like that. She wouldn't be a partner to the spirit of the Shadow cat; she would actually be the Shadow cat herself, but not exactly know who she was, which I can go on n' on about it's so confusing.
As long as she doesn't remember everything about the past, you can go ahead with you plot.
In short, APPROVED.