SO, on your first time through the game, what ending did you get?
Me? I got the good ending on my first try...
I had separate saves, so I technically got both off of my first playthrough.
Bad ending. They really don't give much hint as to how to get the good ending, besides the grail, but I didn't know what it meant the first time through. I actually didn't let my malice fill up once for fear of being owninated.