View Full Version: Evidence List

Addicted To Anthony > >>Canthony Central > Evidence List



Title: Evidence List


Kat - August 30, 2005 04:33 PM (GMT)
This great list was posted by Kenni2009 on IDF. Thought I'd share it with ya'll!

QUOTE
Canthony Evidence:

1. The signing I love you at the vote off
(Everyone and their dog knows about this )

2. Audience sightings say that Carrie ran into his arms in the middle of his song, and clung there for a little while, whispering in his ear at the end.
(Stupid Fox cut this off in favor of Stacked. America simutaneously says WTF?!)

3. The day after being voted off, Ryan asks in a radio interview what was up with the I-love-you. Anthony avoids the question by saying he loves everyone including Ryan himself.
(The first of many dodging the question )

4. Carrie says in interview in her hometown that she received Anthony's key necklace as good luck.
(It is later discovered that said necklace comes in pairs and both are called "keys of love")

5. Anthony and his girlfriend break up. Said girlfriend announces this publically first on his official website's board in a thread titled "Carrie and Anthony". After people say that they don't want to speculate, she adds, "It isn't speculation. It's the truth."
(Just a number of weeks after Carrie and her boyfriend broke up)

6. A TV Guide article is published that describes their friendship, complete with pics and anecdotes of them linking arms and laughing together.
(A TV Guide staff member later goes on TV Guide Channel and says they had the "sweetest relationship")

7. An article bearing the headline "Anthony (sp? I'm not sure what they refer to him as) voted off AI but his love life is getting the attention".
(Unreliable, but nonetheless spoke with supposed sources who said that nobody could stop the relationship and nobody can control where they sleep, among other things)

8. Anthony goes to the Final 3 show as audience member, skipping a scheduled trip home.
(Backstage reports have them acting "flirty".)

9. A mod from Anthony's site writes a long message about how she doesn't believe that they're just friends, that Anthony is a "cheating ass" , and that she has every intention of voting for Bo for as long as possible.
(Post is later deleted.)

10. At the final 2 performance show, the finalists are seated behind the judges, and can all be seen clapping for the final 2. Anthony is the only one shown with an obviously visible preference.
(He, and his empty seat, is the only one shown in close-up as he is applauding. He is also one of the only one seen booing the judges comments, as well as the first to give her standing ovation and the last to sit down, proved by crowd shots. He also gives her a thumbs up, which is almost as though he's communicating with her. During the final critique, he is standing up the whole time, even longer than Carrie's family.)

11. On the Tuesday night before the finale, Anthony's official website endorses Carrie stating that while they both did good, they AGREE WITH ANTHONY that Carrie should win, and only give out her numbers.
(After some negative comments, they edit the message to give out both contestant's numbers. They still have the sentence about believing Carrie should win in there, though .)

12. On the finale, Anthony stands next to her the whole show after the announcement. When he gives her a congratulations hug and kiss (sidenote: panned away from; grr, America is in outrage, cameramen!!), the microphone is able to pick up what many believe is, "I love you and I'm so proud of you." *confirmed by audience members*
(Published pictures from after the cameras cut out reveal more of Canthony's cheering and holding her close.)

13. Granny Madge, Bo's "famous" grandmother gives several interviews after the show ends. The first says that (paraphrased) Canthony is together but she doesn't really know the details. The second, she describes Carrie as "crazy" about Anthony.

14. When the top 10 are interviewed on ET a significant amount of time is given to Canthony. A shot of Anthony giving Carrie a massage is sliced in. When asked why he is blushing when asked about Carrie, all the finalists burst into hysterics, and Carrie weakly claims "he's been tanning."
(It is here that we also found out that Bo sent Anthony flowers from Carrie saying "soon our love will bloom". It is later discovered he sent Carrie flowers from Anthony on the night he was voted off, with the message, "I will always love you.")

15. Anthony is asked once again about whether they're a couple for an InsideTV article he responds with, "We're very good friends. That's all I wish to say."

16. The National Enquirer comes out, with rumors of their "affair".
(Although the NE is not to be believed and had most of its information from so-called anonymous sources who never prove to be real, Carrie's mother is also interviewed. When asked whether Barrie exsists she says (paraphrased), "They're like brother and sister, that's all." When asked about Canthony, she didn't wish to comment.)

17. Carrie is spotted visibly wearing her key necklace around in public appearances, shortly after the NE reported that Anthony called it "the key to his heart."

18. Anthony sings in the national anthem at a basketball game in MSG in an underpublicized performance. Several people report a blonde girl in a hat, shying away from cameras, accompaining him and holding his hand. One person even claims she got an autograph.
(Carrie is also in NYC around this time for appearances.)

19. When introducing Anthony at a nascar event, Ryan calls him Carrie's "good friend".
(Nobody else gets an introduction mentioning "friends".)

20. Several other news outlets pickup on this story. When mentioning Carrie, several newcasted mention the dating rumors. A short article is published talking about "the man who makes Carrie smile".

21. During a post-show interview on the idol website, the Jaded Journists ask if Carrie will stick to country music. Bo says, "What country? Russia?" Carrie jokingly says, "I love ze Russian people."
(This is also the first of many interviews where Carrie refuses to look the interviewer in the eye when saying, "I am boyfriendless." Instead, she looks down. Bo looks amused by this and quickly makes a joke out of the situation, changing the subject.)

22. On Larry King Live, Bo jokingly moves in to kiss Carrie. She immediately looks uncomfortable by this and moves away quickly.
(Also on this interview she is quoted as (jokingly)saying that people will be able to read her diary when "they find out about [her] having an affair with someone on the show."

23. As the idols are in LA rehearsing, there are several sightings of the two of them, one at a movie of Bewitched (*recently confirmed by Carrie in a radio interview*), one of them shopping at Target, one of them shopping, along with Vonzell, and one (doubtful, but still reported) sighting of them buying perfume.
(All report them acting "coupley" and hold hands. The reporter of the Target one is not a Canthony fan.)

24. During Top 4 dress rehearsals, as the four were practicing the lining up with Ryan, Carrie was sighted bumping shoulders with Anthony, as Anthony was just laughing with her.

25. Anthony and Carrie were spotted leaving the Fox studios together after the top three results show (aka, when we start finding out that Anthony was scheduled to go home but he never showed up). There are pictures so this is not to be doubted at all. Vonzell and Bo left on their own though and Carrie was overheard calling Anthony "Anty Bear". We all know that Carrie's called Care Bear (or her fans are) so...you know...Bear and Bear?

26. Sam Rubin, who is an entertainment reporter for KTLA, attended the finale. He said on his show that Anthony would pound his heart after Carrie performed and that a show insider told him Anthony is really in love with her. People who reported this say that Sam is reliable and doesn't make stuff up.

27. In an interview, Carrie's mom is asked about the elimination nights are. She answers that they are very hard and that she cried when Anthony was voted off.

28. A Florida news affiliate reports that Carrie and "her boyfriend" were kicked off the beach because of hurricane warnings.
(It has also been reported [but uncomfirmed] on other boards that Vonzell took the finalists Key West while on a break from rehearsals. Another report has Carrie and Anthony getting kicked off a beach because of hurricane warnings. You'd think that she wouldn't need to be warned more than once, so Anthony and her boyfriend are actually the same person.)

29. Reportedly, Carrie locked herself in her room crying the night of Anthony's elimination.
(Unconfirmed)

30. Recently posted at another board (a Bo board, nothing to do with Anthony OR Carrie): "Recent celeb sighting by a friend in NYC: Carrie and Anthony with their respective parents. Of course the tabloids had Carrie playing around with both Anthony and Bo, but I didn't believe it then and still don't. But Carrie and Anthony make a nice couple."
(Carrie and Anthony had both been in New York the same time frame.)

31. The Idols are performing in Florida today and awhile ago, they were on the radio. Bo teased about Canthony! Bo was like: "Yeah, this morning, Carrie did Anthony's hair." And Carrie was like: "I think it's cute..." And Anthony sounded all embarrassed. Bo was like: "She was going to put ribbons in his hair." And Carrie replied with: "No, I wasn't! ... His hair is too short anyway." And the DJ's asked if Anthony had a crush on Carrie. There was silence and he laughed a little. Carrie was like: "Next question!" And the DJ's were like: "So, you guys do like eachother then?" Carrie: "I didn't say that!" They DJ's replied with: "Then why are you avoiding it...?" She said it was because they always get asked. Then the DJ's were like: "We were just kidding with you guys. But if you do happen to date, it's no one's business, right?" And Carrie was like: "Right..." And everyone laughed.
(When this story is posted on the WIO boards, Anthony's friend, one of the mods, responds with simply a face. Nothing else. In fact, lately, he's been replying in all Canthony threads with either a or a , nothing more.)

32. During the Tampa show, while the group was singing "Lean On Me", during the line about "all you have to do is call", Carrie and Anthony looked at each other and did the call me sign and then laughed. Also, there was another moment later when Anthony looked back at Carrie during, "Rock in the USA" and she shook her head and smiled.

33. After the Tampa show, a fan backstage noticed this, "Back when we were still waiting, I saw Anthony walking behind Carrie near the buses and spanking her butt as they walked (like she wasn't walking fast enough)."

34. During "God Bless the Broken Road", Bo was teasing her about telling the audience about the story behind this song. and she giggled and played it off, "Wait now just a second, you're setting me up for something. We didn't talk about this before."

35. At a party after the show, all the idols were in attendance except Carrie and Anthony.
(It was speculated that Carrie was sent off to record. But where was Anthony? Wishing her bon voyage in his own special way? Or was he accompaining her?)

36. During the Alabama show, a fan reported, saying, "I also used my binoculars to catch glimpses of the idols while they were standing on the side of the stage. I saw some flirting going on between Carrie and Anthony...she kept trying to tickle him and he would pull away...it was cute."

37. Pre-Greensboro show, a fan who met up with the idols at the hotel gave his account: "I just got back from the hotel in Greensboro, NC where the Idols were staying and I got to meet Carrie and Anthony!!! First of all I just want to say that they are soooo sweet!!! Anyways, Anthony came down to the lobby first and he signed some stuff for me and everyone else (there were only like 10 people) and then he just kinda waited around. Then Carrie came down and signed stuff and we figured out that Anthony was waiting on Carrie! They looked sooo cute!!! They were definantly FLIRTING with one another, he would say something to her and then she would start laughing and slap his arm!! But never the less they were majorly flirting and it was really cute!!"

38. A Constantine fan at the Greensboro show reported flirting going on between Anthony and Carrie at the buses after the show.

39. An IDF poster claimed to have gotten an email from a friend who has able to go backstage. In the email, the person stated that Anthony came to talk to everyone but was sleepy the whole time. Then, Carrie came out, gave him a massage underneath his shirt and the two went off to take a nap in his their dressing room(s).
(Reliable? Not likely. But if true, adorable, nonetheless.)

40. In an interview, Carrie was quoted as saying, "I'm still getting used to people recognizing me and stuff," she said. "Me and Anthony [Fedorov, another "Idol" finalist] went shopping in L.A. a few weeks ago, and people would come up to us and say, 'You go shopping, too?' They saw us at Wal-Mart and said, 'You guys go to Wal-Mart?' and we're like, 'Are you kidding? We love Wal-Mart.' We're just normal people."
(Not only is this showing that she is slowly getting more comfortable bringing up Anthony's name, but it basically confirms rumors that they were spotted shopping around with his hand in her back pocket.)

41. Someone said the Nikko told them that the boys share a bus and the girls share a bus. But then another poster said, "Well when they pulled into our hotel (we stayed at the same hotel as the Idols) at 2 AM, Anthony got off of the bus with Carrie and the other girls. They were all in sleep clothes." The girl who talked to Nikko said, "Yeah, Constantine got off the girl bus too once. Maybe they bus hop if they're hanging out or something." Then hotel girl said, "That makes sense. It was cute though cause they we're sleepwalking. All of them looked real cranky at having to wake up and check into the hotel."

42. Someone was listening a few weeks back to an interview Carrie gave to a Texas Country station. Carrie at the time was in LA at reheasals. It had to be very early in the morning. Because Carrie made the comment that is was very early to be giddy. The interviewer asked if she were at a party because it was loud. She said no its was the TV. They asked her what she was watching and she said kinda embarassed a Chevy Chase movie. They asked if she was up to a certain part of the movie and Carrie replied "We're" not up to that part yet.
(It's early in the morning in your room and you are watching a movie with someone. Hmm? Also the movie was "Spies Like Us" which if you have seen it is a spy movie and has some scenes with agents ending up in Russia and scenes of them talking russian. I wonder who would like that movie?)

43. An IDF poster said her friend went to the concert & met Carrie in the Reading, PA concert. She asked Carrie where Anthony was and Carrie said that Anthony was with his family (since its a PA concert). The girl then asked if Anthony smells good and Carrie said that Anthony does smell good and sometimes she just want to sniff him the whole day.
(Who sniffs their brother all day?)

44. From IDF (posted by whylive08):
went to the Tampa, FL concert last July 13th... didn't get the best seats, but it was on the left corner where we can kinda see what's going on backstage. I didn't see Carrie until Anthony was performing. She went backstage to videotape Anthony singing for a little bit, then she went back in (for me, it was as if she was sneaking... as if she didn't want anybody to see her videotaping Anthony... well, maybe it was just me).

45. A poster on the official forums reported Anthony sitting with the techs and watching Carrie's performances (and only hers, no one elses) at a recent concert.

46. The Big Brother houseguests were staying in the same as the idols while on tour. One of them stayed in the room next to Carrie and said she would see Anthony going into her room and...that's when the live feed cut out.

47. When asked (in an interview) who smelled the best Anthony answered, "I don't know if it's the best but I guess Carrie. (pause) She always smelled...." (trails off and sighs)

48. Anthony comes out, and we scream “ANTHOY!” He looks up and waves and I hold up my "Carrie Kiss Anthony" sign and he looked at it, and he started smiling wider than the ocean!!!!!!! I asked him if he could bring Carrie out and he said, "I'll try my best hun!" He walked in still smiling, and I think I had made his day!

49. At the concert in cleveland last night during rock in the usa carrie would like walk by anthony all...i dont know how to say it um "sexily" haha lmao yeah i dont know how to describe it but she'd do it around him and he was staring at her like this yeah. and then one time (i was on the floor in the 8th row on the side so i could see it like really good) she ran behind him and smacked his butt and ran away and smiled.

50. I had a sign that said "CANTHONY!" for the tour [i was 4th row] during r-o-c-k in the usa...bo saw it and laughed at me lol then looked over to carrie and anthony but they were on the other side of the stage

51. A fan gave a Anthony a polar bear as a present. Recently, taht same polar bear was (we THINK) spotted on the girl's tour bus on a rack of all Carrie's bears. Must've been a present...

52.At the chicago show during Lean On Me Anthony chucked and waves at me after he saw my "Anthony Kiss Carrie" sign

53.Anthony snuck in between Carrie And nikko before they bowed....soo cute

54. After the Chicago show Anthony brought out some stuff and put it on one bus, then he went back inside the venue,then he came out with another bag and got on teh other bus,( he did not egt off ater that) about 5 minutes later Nikko came out and pu a bag on the bus Anthony went to first, then Anwar and Scott came out and went to the same bus Nikko was on, then all 3 of them went inside. But Anthony remained on the other bus, one would ocnclude that Anthony was on the girls bus.

55. When they were in Oaklahoma Anthony got very emotional.

56. A fan saw Carrie video taping Anthony during his set while they were in Oaklahoma, when teh girl wave dto Carrie she waved back.

57. In an interview in Oaklahoma Carrie to Anthony as her "security blanket"

58. When they talked about teh bus wars on E news Anthony was sitting with Connie the reporter asked Connie if he was single but did not ask Anthony.

59. When they had the wheel game on Teen NIck teh host spun teh wheel and it was going to land on love. The expresion onCarrie's face was priceless and the host then moved it to bling.

60. During the San Jose show, there was heavy "butt bumping" during "Rock the USA".

61. After everyone took their bows as they were walking across stage, Carrie kept "trying to kick him, you know, lots of flirting".

62. In a recent interview, when asked who her best friend was she responded with, "My best friend is definitely Anthony. I talk to Mikalah and Lindsey, too. But Anthony . . . he's such a great guy. We like to do the same things. We're not partiers. I'm not a dancer. We'll go to the mall, go out to eat, that kind of thing."
(not only does the confirm their closeness, but this confirms nearly EVERY SINGLE SIGHTING of them.)

63. They were both seen watching Bo's set together at a concert.

64. A fan saw them (around the time of meet and greets) together at a recent concert, him playing with her hair.

65. An IDF poster said: (of a meet and greet)"Carrie was really sweet and shy! I think she was tired or not feeling well cuz when she came out she sat at the table waiting for us to go down and she had her head down on the table. Then Anthony came and sat by here and patted her back! It was so cute. They they started playing "let mess up each other hair!" It was so cute! They kept messing you each others hair over and over again! lol. I gave Carrie her fan book. She was like Thank you and smiled and looked at it."

66. They both wore each other's support bracelets on their left hand in concert.

67. By IriteChoco: "At my concert meet and greet (Hartford, CT: 7/29), my friend had an Anthony poster and set it down on the table. While my friend was talking to Bo & Anthony as they were signing, Carrie scribbles "I love your poster!" on her ANTHONY poster. She must love the poster 'cause she loves Anthony! LOL!"
(the poster said "Without Anthony... I'd be INCOMPLETE" aww.)


Hmmm. I think I remember that 'call me' part at the Tampa concert, now that I think about it. What about you, Nova?

Nova - August 31, 2005 08:10 AM (GMT)
Hmm...Nuuuupe, can't say I saw that. WAH! That would have been so cool to see. We should have asked him when we met him if he and Carrie were going out yet. XD

And DUDE, why aren't those two married yet?! XDD

Kat - August 31, 2005 04:09 PM (GMT)
Well we should have screamed that thing we planned. "We'll fight you for Anthony!" to Carrie. XD

MargoK - September 16, 2005 03:24 AM (GMT)
I posted the following on Anthony's Message Board on the IDF forums:

CAnthony HAS to be real. I was just looking at some CAnthony pictures and thinking how much in love they look.

I tried to get onto my account on the CAnthony forums, but I can't remember my user name!

Anyway, I know that the night that Anthony was voted off has been discussed over and over. However, I'm not sure if we have talked about the conflicting stories that Carrie has told about her signing "I love you."

I have heard that she told some press agents that she was signing "I love you" to her parents. Yeah right! Then of course we've all heard that she was saying that she loves Anthony like a "brother." Again -- yeah right!

This one is the clincher. I heard that Carrie said that "she didn't think they were going to show her signing "I love you" to Anthony. Now, if she thought they wouldn't show that on t.v. then she must have thought it was a "private" moment between her and Anthony.

They are so in love! I just hope they can figure out how to get together and still keep their careers going. I heard that Carrie is moving to Tennessee. Think we'll hear that Anthony is moving there in the near future?

They just look so happy together and in love. I can't imagine them not being together.

Margo

Kat - September 16, 2005 01:51 PM (GMT)
QUOTE (MargoK @ Sep 15 2005, 11:24 PM)
This one is the clincher. I heard that Carrie said that "she didn't think they were going to show her signing "I love you" to Anthony. Now, if she thought they wouldn't show that on t.v. then she must have thought it was a "private" moment between her and Anthony.

Yea, I've heard that too!

iluv_Carrie_n_Canthony - December 3, 2005 05:52 PM (GMT)
i've got that list but it's up 2 like 80 sumthin.....if i find it on my email i'll post it!!! :p

canadiansforanthony - May 15, 2006 03:11 PM (GMT)

Here's the final version of the list.

1. The signing I love you at the vote off
(Everyone and their dog knows about this )

2. Audience sightings say that Carrie ran into his arms in the middle of his song, and clung there for a little while, whispering in his ear at the end.
(Stupid Fox cut this off in favor of Stacked. America simutaneously says WTF?!)

3. The day after being voted off, Ryan asks in a radio interview what was up with the I-love-you. Anthony avoids the question by saying he loves everyone including Ryan himself.
(The first of many dodging the question )

4. Carrie says in interview in her hometown that she received Anthony's key necklace as good luck.
(It is later discovered that said necklace comes in pairs and both are called "keys of love")

5. Anthony and his girlfriend break up. Said girlfriend announces this publically first on his official website's board in a thread titled "Carrie and Anthony". After people say that they don't want to speculate, she adds, "It isn't speculation. It's the truth."
(Just a number of weeks after Carrie and her boyfriend broke up)

6. A TV Guide article is published that describes their friendship, complete with pics and anecdotes of them linking arms and laughing together.
(A TV Guide staff member later goes on TV Guide Channel and says they had the "sweetest relationship")

7. An article bearing the headline "Anthony (sp? I'm not sure what they refer to him as) voted off AI but his love life is getting the attention".
(Unreliable, but nonetheless spoke with supposed sources who said that nobody could stop the relationship and nobody can control where they sleep, among other things)

8. Anthony goes to the Final 3 show as audience member, skipping a scheduled trip home.
(Backstage reports have them acting "flirty".)

9. A mod from Anthony's site writes a long message about how she doesn't believe that they're just friends, that Anthony is a "cheating ass" , and that she has every intention of voting for Bo for as long as possible.
(Post is later deleted.)

10. At the final 2 performance show, the finalists are seated behind the judges, and can all be seen clapping for the final 2. Anthony is the only one shown with an obviously visible preference.
(He, and his empty seat, is the only one shown in close-up as he is applauding. He is also one of the only one seen booing the judges comments, as well as the first to give her standing ovation and the last to sit down, proved by crowd shots. He also gives her a thumbs up, which is almost as though he's communicating with her. During the final critique, he is standing up the whole time, even longer than Carrie's family.)

11. On the Tuesday night before the finale, Anthony's official website endorses Carrie stating that while they both did good, they AGREE WITH ANTHONY that Carrie should win, and only give out her numbers.
(After some negative comments, they edit the message to give out both contestant's numbers. They still have the sentence about believing Carrie should win in there, though .)

12. On the finale, Anthony stands next to her the whole show after the announcement. When he gives her a congratulations hug and kiss (sidenote: panned away from; grr, America is in outrage, cameramen!!), the microphone is able to pick up what many believe is, "I love you and I'm so proud of you." *confirmed by audience members*
(Published pictures from after the cameras cut out reveal more of Canthony's cheering and holding her close.)

13. Granny Madge, Bo's "famous" grandmother gives several interviews after the show ends. The first says that (paraphrased) Canthony is together but she doesn't really know the details. The second, she describes Carrie as "crazy" about Anthony.

14. When the top 10 are interviewed on ET a significant amount of time is given to Canthony. A shot of Anthony giving Carrie a massage is sliced in. When asked why he is blushing when asked about Carrie, all the finalists burst into hysterics, and Carrie weakly claims "he's been tanning."
(It is here that we also found out that Bo sent Anthony flowers from Carrie saying "soon our love will bloom". It is later discovered he sent Carrie flowers from Anthony on the night he was voted off, with the message, "I will always love you.")

15. Anthony is asked once again about whether they're a couple for an InsideTV article he responds with, "We're very good friends. That's all I wish to say."

16. The National Enquirer comes out, with rumors of their "affair".
(Although the NE is not to be believed and had most of its information from so-called anonymous sources who never prove to be real, Carrie's mother is also interviewed. When asked whether Barrie exsists she says (paraphrased), "They're like brother and sister, that's all." When asked about Canthony, she didn't wish to comment.)

17. Carrie is spotted visibly wearing her key necklace around in public appearances, shortly after the NE reported that Anthony called it "the key to his heart."

18. Anthony sings in the national anthem at a basketball game in MSG in an underpublicized performance. Several people report a blonde girl in a hat, shying away from cameras, accompaining him and holding his hand. One person even claims she got an autograph.
(Carrie is also in NYC around this time for appearances.)

19. When introducing Anthony at a nascar event, Ryan calls him Carrie's "good friend".
(Nobody else gets an introduction mentioning "friends".)

20. Several other news outlets pickup on this story. When mentioning Carrie, several newcasted mention the dating rumors. A short article is published talking about "the man who makes Carrie smile".

21. During a post-show interview on the idol website, the Jaded Journists ask if Carrie will stick to country music. Bo says, "What country? Russia?" Carrie jokingly says, "I love ze Russian people."
(This is also the first of many interviews where Carrie refuses to look the interviewer in the eye when saying, "I am boyfriendless." Instead, she looks down. Bo looks amused by this and quickly makes a joke out of the situation, changing the subject.)

22. On Larry King Live, Bo jokingly moves in to kiss Carrie. She immediately looks uncomfortable by this and moves away quickly.
(Also on this interview she is quoted as (jokingly)saying that people will be able to read her diary when "they find out about [her] having an affair with someone on the show."

23. As the idols are in LA rehearsing, there are several sightings of the two of them, one at a movie of Bewitched (*recently confirmed by Carrie in a radio interview*), one of them shopping at Target, one of them shopping, along with Vonzell, and one (doubtful, but still reported) sighting of them buying perfume.
(All report them acting "coupley" and holding hands. The reporter of the Target one is not a Canthony fan.)

24. During Top 4 dress rehearsals, as the four were practicing the lining up with Ryan, Carrie was sighted bumping shoulders with Anthony, as Anthony was just laughing with her.

25. Anthony and Carrie were spotted leaving the Fox studios together after the top three results show (aka, when we start finding out that Anthony was scheduled to go home but he never showed up). There are pictures so this is not to be doubted at all. Vonzell and Bo left on their own though and Carrie was overheard calling Anthony "Anty Bear". We all know that Carrie's called Care Bear (or her fans are) so...you know...Bear and Bear?

26. Sam Rubin, who is an entertainment reporter for KTLA, attended the finale. He said on his show that Anthony would pound his heart after Carrie performed and that a show insider told him Anthony is really in love with her. People who reported this say that Sam is reliable and doesn't make stuff up.

27. In an interview, Carrie's mom is asked how the elimination nights are. She answers that they are very hard and that she cried when Anthony was voted off.

28. A Florida news affiliate reports that Carrie and "her boyfriend" were kicked off the beach because of hurricane warnings.
(It has also been reported [but uncomfirmed] on other boards that Vonzell took the finalists Key West while on a break from rehearsals. Another report has Carrie and Anthony getting kicked off a beach because of hurricane warnings. You'd think that she wouldn't need to be warned more than once, so Anthony and her boyfriend are actually the same person.)

29. Reportedly, Carrie locked herself in her room crying the night of Anthony's elimination.
(Unconfirmed)

30. Recently posted at another board (a Bo board, nothing to do with Anthony OR Carrie): "Recent celeb sighting by a friend in NYC: Carrie and Anthony with their respective parents. Of course the tabloids had Carrie playing around with both Anthony and Bo, but I didn't believe it then and still don't. But Carrie and Anthony make a nice couple."
(Carrie and Anthony had both been in New York the same time frame.)

31. The Idols are performing in Florida today and awhile ago, they were on the radio. Bo teased about Canthony! Bo was like: "Yeah, this morning, Carrie did Anthony's hair." And Carrie was like: "I think it's cute..." And Anthony sounded all embarrassed. Bo was like: "She was going to put ribbons in his hair." And Carrie replied with: "No, I wasn't! ... His hair is too short anyway." And the DJ's asked if Anthony had a crush on Carrie. There was silence and he laughed a little. Carrie was like: "Next question!" And the DJ's were like: "So, you guys do like eachother then?" Carrie: "I didn't say that!" They DJ's replied with: "Then why are you avoiding it...?" She said it was because they always get asked. Then the DJ's were like: "We were just kidding with you guys. But if you do happen to date, it's no one's business, right?" And Carrie was like: "Right..." And everyone laughed.
(When this story is posted on the WIO boards, Anthony's friend, one of the mods, responds with simply a face. Nothing else. In fact, lately, he's been replying in all Canthony threads with either a or a , nothing more.)

32. During the Tampa show, while the group was singing "Lean On Me", during the line about "all you have to do is call", Carrie and Anthony looked at each other and did the call me sign and then laughed. Also, there was another moment later when Anthony looked back at Carrie during, "Rock in the USA" and she shook her head and smiled.

33. After the Tampa show, a fan backstage noticed this, "Back when we were still waiting, I saw Anthony walking behind Carrie near the buses and spanking her butt as they walked (like she wasn't walking fast enough)."

34. During "God Bless the Broken Road", Bo was teasing her about telling the audience about the story behind this song. and she giggled and played it off, "Wait now just a second, you're setting me up for something. We didn't talk about this before."

35. At a party after the show, all the idols were in attendance except Carrie and Anthony.
(It was speculated that Carrie was sent off to record. But where was Anthony? Wishing her bon voyage in his own special way? Or was he accompaining her?)

36. During the Alabama show, a fan reported, saying, "I also used my binoculars to catch glimpses of the idols while they were standing on the side of the stage. I saw some flirting going on between Carrie and Anthony...she kept trying to tickle him and he would pull away...it was cute."

37. Pre-Greensboro show, a fan who met up with the idols at the hotel gave his account: "I just got back from the hotel in Greensboro, NC where the Idols were staying and I got to meet Carrie and Anthony!!! First of all I just want to say that they are soooo sweet!!! Anyways, Anthony came down to the lobby first and he signed some stuff for me and everyone else (there were only like 10 people) and then he just kinda waited around. Then Carrie came down and signed stuff and we figured out that Anthony was waiting on Carrie! They looked sooo cute!!! They were definantly FLIRTING with one another, he would say something to her and then she would start laughing and slap his arm!! But never the less they were majorly flirting and it was really cute!!"

38. A Constantine fan at the Greensboro show reported flirting going on between Anthony and Carrie at the buses after the show.

39. An IDF poster claimed to have gotten an email from a friend who has able to go backstage. In the email, the person stated that Anthony came to talk to everyone but was sleepy the whole time. Then, Carrie came out, gave him a massage underneath his shirt and the two went off to take a nap in his their dressing room(s).
(Reliable? Not likely. But if true, adorable, nonetheless.)

40. In an interview, Carrie was quoted as saying, "I'm still getting used to people recognizing me and stuff," she said. "Me and Anthony [Fedorov, another "Idol" finalist] went shopping in L.A. a few weeks ago, and people would come up to us and say, 'You go shopping, too?' They saw us at Wal-Mart and said, 'You guys go to Wal-Mart?' and we're like, 'Are you kidding? We love Wal-Mart.' We're just normal people."
(Not only is this showing that she is slowly getting more comfortable bringing up Anthony's name, but it basically confirms rumors that they were spotted shopping around with his hand in her back pocket.)

41. Someone said that Nikko told them that the boys share a bus and the girls share a bus. But then another poster said, "Well when they pulled into our hotel (we stayed at the same hotel as the Idols) at 2 AM, Anthony got off of the bus with Carrie and the other girls. They were all in sleep clothes." The girl who talked to Nikko said, "Yeah, Constantine got off the girl bus too once. Maybe they bus hop if they're hanging out or something." Then hotel girl said, "That makes sense. It was cute though cause they we're sleepwalking. All of them looked real cranky at having to wake up and check into the hotel."

42. Someone was listening a few weeks back to an interview Carrie gave to a Texas Country station. Carrie at the time was in LA at reheasals. It had to be very early in the morning. Because Carrie made the comment that is was very early to be giddy. The interviewer asked if she were at a party because it was loud. She said no its was the TV. They asked her what she was watching and she said kinda embarassed a Chevy Chase movie. They asked if she was up to a certain part of the movie and Carrie replied "We're" not up to that part yet.
(It's early in the morning in your room and you are watching a movie with someone. Hmm? Also the movie was "Spies Like Us" which if you have seen it is a spy movie and has some scenes with agents ending up in Russia and scenes of them talking russian. I wonder who would like that movie?)

43. An IDF poster said her friend went to the concert & met Carrie in the Reading, PA concert. She asked Carrie where Anthony was and Carrie said that Anthony was with his family (since its a PA concert). The girl then asked if Anthony smells good and Carrie said that Anthony does smell good and sometimes she just want to sniff him the whole day.
(Who sniffs their brother all day?)

44. From IDF (posted by whylive08):
went to the Tampa, FL concert last July 13th... didn't get the best seats, but it was on the left corner where we can kinda see what's going on backstage. I didn't see Carrie until Anthony was performing. She went backstage to videotape Anthony singing for a little bit, then she went back in (for me, it was as if she was sneaking... as if she didn't want anybody to see her videotaping Anthony... well, maybe it was just me).

45. A poster on the official forums reported Anthony sitting with the techs and watching Carrie's performances (and only hers, no one elses) at a recent concert.

46. The Big Brother houseguests were staying in the same as the idols while on tour. One of them stayed in the room next to Carrie and said she would see Anthony going into her room and...that's when the live feed cut out.

47. When asked (in an interview) who smelled the best Anthony answered, "I don't know if it's the best but I guess Carrie. (pause) She always smelled...." (trails off and sighs)

48. Anthony comes out, and we scream “ANTHONY!” He looks up and waves and I hold up my "Carrie Kiss Anthony" sign and he looked at it, and he started smiling wider than the ocean!!!!!!! I asked him if he could bring Carrie out and he said, "I'll try my best hun!" He walked in still smiling, and I think I had made his day!

49. At the concert in cleveland last night during rock in the usa carrie would like walk by anthony all...i dont know how to say it um "sexily" haha lmao yeah i dont know how to describe it but she'd do it around him and he was staring at her like this yeah. and then one time (i was on the floor in the 8th row on the side so i could see it like really good) she ran behind him and smacked his butt and ran away and smiled.

50. I had a sign that said "CANTHONY!" for the tour [i was 4th row] during r-o-c-k in the usa...bo saw it and laughed at me lol then looked over to carrie and anthony but they were on the other side of the stage

51. A fan gave a Anthony a polar bear as a present. Recently, taht same polar bear was (we THINK) spotted on the girl's tour bus on a rack of all Carrie's bears. Must've been a present...

52.At the chicago show during Lean On Me Anthony chucked and waves at me after he saw my "Anthony Kiss Carrie" sign

53.Anthony snuck in between Carrie And nikko before they bowed....soo cute

54. After the Chicago show Anthony brought out some stuff and put it on one bus, then he went back inside the venue,then he came out with another bag and got on teh other bus,( he did not egt off ater that) about 5 minutes later Nikko came out and put a bag on the bus Anthony went to first, then Anwar and Scott came out and went to the same bus Nikko was on, then all 3 of them went inside. But Anthony remained on the other bus, one would conclude that Anthony was on the girls bus.

55. When they were in Oklahoma Anthony got very emotional.

56. A fan saw Carrie video taping Anthony during his set while they were in Oaklahoma, when the girl waved to Carrie she waved back.

57. In an interview in Oklahoma Carrie refered to Anthony as her "security blanket"

58. When they talked about the bus wars on E news Anthony was sitting with Connie the reporter asked Connie if he was single but did not ask Anthony.

59. When they had the wheel game on Teen NIck teh host spun the wheel and it was going to land on love. The expresion onCarrie's face was priceless and the host then moved it to bling.

60. During the San Jose show, there was heavy "butt bumping" during "Rock the USA".

61. After everyone took their bows as they were walking across stage, Carrie kept "trying to kick him, you know, lots of flirting".

62. In a recent interview, when asked who her best friend was she responded with, "My best friend is definitely Anthony. I talk to Mikalah and Lindsey, too. But Anthony . . . he's such a great guy. We like to do the same things. We're not partiers. I'm not a dancer. We'll go to the mall, go out to eat, that kind of thing."
(not only does the confirm their closeness, but this confirms nearly EVERY SINGLE SIGHTING of them.)

63. They were both seen watching Bo's set together at a concert.

64. A fan saw them (around the time of meet and greets) together at a recent concert, him playing with her hair.

65. An IDF poster said: (of a meet and greet)"Carrie was really sweet and shy! I think she was tired or not feeling well cuz when she came out she sat at the table waiting for us to go down and she had her head down on the table. Then Anthony came and sat by here and patted her back! It was so cute. They they started playing "let mess up each other hair!" It was so cute! They kept messing you each others hair over and over again! lol. I gave Carrie her fan book. She was like Thank you and smiled and looked at it."

66. They both wore each other's support bracelets on their left hand in concert.

67. By IriteChoco: "At my concert meet and greet (Hartford, CT: 7/29), my friend had an Anthony poster and set it down on the table. While my friend was talking to Bo & Anthony as they were signing, Carrie scribbles "I love your poster!" on her ANTHONY poster. She must love the poster 'cause she loves Anthony! LOL!"
(the poster said "Without Anthony... I'd be INCOMPLETE" aww.)

68. ALBANY: "You know how when they sing Call Me and Anwar always sits between Anthony and Carrie... well tonite he was on the other side of Anthony but still a step above him so it went Carrie Anthony(step below) and then Anwar... Well Carrie came out and sang her part and then kinda plopped down and Anthony got up and sat right next to her like touching her and she kinda put up her feet like she was kicking him and pushed him away laughing so then he went back down to his seat. sooo cute! And then at the very end of the song they were standing next to each other and the last CALLL MEEEEEE (lol) They both sang it to each other and he reached over and like touched her hair or something so she pushed him and then he messed up her hair and ran away."

69. ALBANY: "This one isnt as blatant but during ROCK Anthony kinda lost his shoe and he was trying to fix it and Carrie completely stopped singing and like waited for him to get it back on and he was staring at her laughing while he was bending over...awhhh she cares about him hahaha"

70. ALBANY: "During ROCK in the USA Carrie and Anthony were walking to the other side of the stage and he was like kinda chasing her so she did like a move to get around him and then started laughing hysterically and walked a little bit up the stage..."

71. ALBANY: "And then almost immediately after #3 during that part in ROCK when Cons like ok we're gonna say ROCK in the USA and you guys need to respond Scott had gotten in between Carrie and Anthony and it was almost like he looked at them and was like ohhh woops so he actually walked over to Jessica and started singing over there and then Anthony just walked right up to Carrie like thats right Scott move haha but anyway during that part they always put the mics out to the audience so they can respond and they both put the mic up to each other and then started pushing each other."

72. ALBANY: "Whew and the last one i almost forgot about... At the very end when they come back out to wave goodbye and say thanks... Carrie was on one side of the stage and Anthony was slowly making his way over and he goes right up to her and -brace yourself- bows down and like did that praise you thing with his arms and just starts laughing so when he went to get up she tried to kick his leg."
(68 - 72 thanks blondieee16 at IDF)

73. They were seen at a Thai restaurant in Salt Lake City, sitting close and eating off each other's plates.

74. At the Albany show, Carrie was watching Anthony performing, and he and Constantine were watching her, and talking together.

75. Albany: "Once the whole concert was over and they walked offstage, I used the bincolars to follow them and since they went off stage on different sides and at different times, Anthony had stopped and waited for her towards the stairs that led back to the door. When she got to where he was standing he wrapped his arm around her and pulled her closer to him."

76. From JordiesmyJunior at IDF: "At my hotel apparently they were holding hands and eating breakfest together and going into the giftshop...alone."

77. Anthony posted a message on his website saying he was sick. Concert goers later noticed Carrie's voice sounding sick.

78. At the Salt Lake City hotel, all the idols came down to the lobby by themselves, except for the two of them, who came down together.

79. See page 12 of this thread for the cheesehat/flirting pictures. They all speak for themselves.

80. Posted on IDF by Anthonyfan16: but, when they sang Rock The USA, towards the end, they were kicking each other in the butt, and flirting a lot going off stage. then, coming back on stage, they came out holding hands for maybe a couple seconds but it was all still cute

81. Posted by Starlight623:
Definitely trying to kick each other's butts when they were leaving.

82. In Virginia: "They were joking about the "Call Me" again, and in one song, they crossed their arms and sang into the other's microphone instead of his/her own."

83. Also in Virginia, at the end of the concert "I also saw him grab her on the side of the stage, and he pulled her towards him and then they ran out together back to the stage!"

84. At NJ show, reportings of Anthony messing up Carrie's hair and Carrie playing with anthonys, while they chased one another around the stage!

85. At the last show, they had a water fight onstage.

86. At the last show, he picked her up and twirled her around, and then said "Give me a kiss" and kissed (on the cheek, but just barely). WHAT MORE EVIDENCE DO YOU NEED TO KNOW?

87. Con's fans always notice that Anthony and Carrie are together.
"We saw Carrie and Anthony come down together and pose for pictures with some fans. I am 100% convinced that they are dating, seriously."

88. Connie fan:
"I loved the little ladies from Liverpool. Big Ant fans who came all the way just to meet him...... Carrie and Anthony totally a couple. It is obvious. They just walked out of the hotel together, no security and walked down the street. No one seemed to really bother them. "

89. Con fan:
"And Anthony and Carrie are DEFINITELY a couple..."

90. Another Connie fan i think..
"As for Anthony and Carrie.. they're just very close you can tell... and on Sunday night on stage she literally jumped into his arms... very cute."

91. According to a young fan who went to afterparty in Norman:
in Tulsa, she was crying and she was like "thats my mommy of there!! wave and say hi!!" it was really funny.. and then after the show, i saw her and anthony MAJOR flirtage and i was like giving her this look that was like "Girl, He tuched your BOOTAY, your a cuple!!" and she came over and just said, "i know what you are thinking.. and you are wrong." i looked at her with a funny face and just said, " then prove me wrong.." HAHAHAHAHAHA

92. well what made it funnier was the reaction that i got from anthony.. like he was about to pee his pants laughing so hard.. cause im young, and he was all "YOU GOT TOLD!" haha i was at that lil' "triangle pass party" - thats the name i officially gave it, cause nobody had a name for it.. haha.. she looked like she wanted to slap me, but with this forced smile.. then my brother came to save me.. hahahaha

93. "well.. lol.. i was at the party and anthony was like hitting her butt.. and then he'd try to impress her by dancing in front of her.. <that was hilarious.. and they walked out arm in arm.. lol.. i talked with carrie for a lil' bit and i just kept telling her that i knew they were together.. then i said "Girl.. dont give me lip, i know yall are together.." and anthony almost peed himself cause well, im pretty young and i just like told her off.. lolez.. she laughed but looked like she wanted to absolutly kill me.. lol.. then she said it was all good when i went to her crying.. "

94. How about the after concert party near the end of tour when Anthony nor Carrie were in attendance? One of the Idols said the reason was that Anthony was sick and Carrie was taking care of him.

95. the "your #1" exchange from the syracuse 10th video. Too cute!

96. the picture where anthony looks at Carrie with a pouty face after
seeing the "Yes, I will marry you Anthony" sign.

97. When Constantine makes that hand gesture ushing the two together right
before the water fight

98. Picture of Anthony handing Carrie the bunny

99. Butt smacking video from Norfolk

100.(iluvfedorwood) well i know its a little late.... but i have some canthony moments from the first syracuse show... bc i was on the side so i could them backstage.. and carrie came out and watched anthony sing... and then he came off it looked like he gave her a kiss on the cheek and then she pulled away.. like in a joking way.... and he said something to her..... then constantine... came running up.. and it looked like he was joking with them.... and then when bo was performing carrie and anthony were dancing together for a little... and then carrie did this really funny dance move.... and anthony did that crazy sign... then when all the guys were suppposed to go on the one side of the stage for sweet hoome alabama... carrie spanked anthonys butt to get him moving.... and then anthony was the only one i saw who watched carrie sing... and then i was staying at their hotel... and i knew everyone was at the party except for carrie and bo.... and someone said that they were sleeping.. then anthony came down... and he called someone on his phone.. and was like were you sleeping.. and they had to have said no... bc he was like good... ill call you back in ten minutes i have a crazy proposition for us.. and then later my sis was in the elevator with anth.. and she said he had his swimming trunks on and was going to the ninth floor..... so that could have possibly been to meet carrie.... bc after he got off. my sis said the elevator stopped on the idols floor but carrie didnt get on.... she stayed there.... but nadia got on.... so i dont know....

101. (greenleo) I've been watching some of Carrie's performances from the finale...there are apparently a few things I've missed back in May..lol...After her song Iniside Your Heaven, we all know how Anthony is shown clapping for her...and is the only idol really shown rooting for her...well, when the judges are talking about her song and telling her how she did, they show Anthony and then you hear someone shout "I love you Carrie!" really loudly..well, when I originaly heard that I just thought it was one of the fans in the audience...but then I listened to the voice, and I can guarantee that it was Anthony...cuz then they showed the judges, and watch Jessica closely..she is seating behind Randy and the last one on the left and after the "i love you Carrie" shout...she starts laughing and looks at Anthony...if I'm correct, I am also pretty sure that he shouted "i love you" twice...not one after the other...if you watch the scene closely, you can actually hear that it's Anthony's voice...

AND when she was singing Angels Brought Me Here...not only did she only face the audience the WHOLE time looking straight at where Anthony was seating...without really moving her head at all..just looking in one direction, straight forward...as though she was singing the song to Anthony...well, I've noticed that when the camera showed the judges while Carrie was singing the song, watch Simon VERY CLOSELY...cuz his head is turned to the left and it looks like he is staring at where Anthony is seating...the other two judges are staring at Carrie, but for some reason, Simon is looking back to the left...also at the end Carrie got very emotional, ready to cry...

102. (Katie) Ummm, this isn't big evidence or anything, but after the Portland, ME (9/9) show Carrie went on the bus after signing autographs (unfortunately, I didn't get one...) and she never came off. After Anthony signed autographs (I did get his!) he went on the bus Carrie went on, and I'm 99% sure that no other girl from the top 10 was on it... he came off maybe 15 minutes later though.

103. (federov21) carrie got that stuffed animal bunny from a fan that when you push the paw it says i love you and anthony kept going up to her and pushing it over and over again.

104. (Randon Post-Tour Moments Thread) carrie and anthony both went on one tour bus after the september 10 show alone, and when they came out like 10 minutes later they changed. dont know if its good but its something lol


104 PIECES OF EVIDENCE!!!! try denying it now, canthony




Hosted for free by InvisionFree