Ace Young sings “Drops of Jupiter.” Randy Jackson says “Once again completely the wrong song for you and you didn’t sing it well.” Paul Abdul says “To me, it wasn’t my favorite.” Paula also notices Ace’s scar. Simon Cowell says “That wasn’t a great vocal.” Ace reveals that the secret behind his scar is that he was playing basketball and he landed on a t-bar.

It’s tough to say who will be going home from tonight’s show. Past results would indicate that Ace Young, Lisa Tucker, and Bucky Covington had the most to prove tonight. The judges were harsh on Ace, but in our opinion, it was one of his best performances, and he was far from the worst tonight. Our prediction is that Bucky Covington, Mandisa, and Lisa Tucker will wind up in the bottom three, and Lisa Tucker will be going home, because she had a lackluster performance in the dreaded opening spot