Link - Season 4 story

Season 4 Heartthrob: Constantine Maroulis

Squeal rating: 9

What made him hot: Scorching looks at the camera and come-hither eye contact with women in the crowd. Made the most of tight pants and rocker vibe.

Melting moment: A lounge-lizard version of "My Funny Valentine," which caused millions of hearts to flutter.

Seasons 1, 2 & 3 Heartthrobs are posted in the forum for those seasons.


Who do you think is the heartthrob for Season 5? Which season's heartthrob has the highest rated "squeal factor"? Go to the members' Media section to find out!

:no:

I really think it should say "squick" rating instead of "squeal" rating.

To me, there really wasn't a heartthrob last year, but Constantine came the closest, I guess. Anthony was kinda cute, too. Didn't really get Bo at all. And Scott?!?!?!?!?!? :omg: Were there other guys? (How quickly they forget! :rolleyes:)

Ace is still the best looking guy they've ever had on Idol but it's not just looks. He definitely has talent, too.

Frenchie -- go here -- http://s11.invisionfree.com/Ace_High/index.php?showtopic=219 and read about the Season 5 Heartthrob!


:ace8:

:thumbsup:

See? I knew I had good taste! :whistle: That many women can't be all wrong! :P

I agree with Frenchie. There wasn't a huge hearthrob last year, but Constantine came closest. Looking at him now though, I kick myself for ever thinking he was hot, because compared to Ace? Constantine is hot buttered Ass(chin).

I think Bo is sexier now. Except when he's sweaty. Ew.

I love Connie!!! :wub:

I was a Fed girl last year..... :wub: ........Anthony is turning into a hot young man.........

Oh!! Isn't he dating somebody who is also from AI? I read something somewhere But I forgot who it was!!

LAST YEAR: I WAS A BO AND CONSTAINE GIRL( STILL AM)

SEASON 3: JPL
SEAON 2: JOSH GRACIN

THIS SEASON.....................................
OF COURSE ACE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and CHRIS tooo

and.........Bucky was sowly growing on me!

Last year, I was in love with Constantine and Bo. I still love Bo very much, but lost all my love for Constantine. Finding out very hurtful things about Con's behavior turned me away from him permanently.

I know he left his band, but what else has he done?

I can't go into it on here. If you want to know, please PM me and I will explain it all to you.

I agree; I dont think there was really a heart throb of season 4 OR season 2. If anyone, I'd have to say that Anthony was last season. Season two was basically based on talent, which every season should be, IMO.

for me

Season 1-Justin
Season 2-Clay
Season 3-JPL
Season 4-Anthony :wub: :wub: :wub:
Season 5-The one and only ACE! :wub: :wub: :wub: :heartbeat:

for me there really wasn't a heartthrob...constantine was actually kinda ugly to me.....and bo ewww so ya I really didn't think there was one last year...